Ambitions to improve EU’s security of supply

  Enquire / contact me

Unintended consequences of an ambitious EU energy efficiency target

Ambitions to improve EU’s security of supply
Ambitions to improve EU’s security of supply
Susanne Hounsell
Susanne Hounsell

Political events over the past six months have revived ambitions to improve the EU's security of supply. Since the onset of the Ukraine crisis, reducing fuel import dependency has become a key interest for EU energy policy. After all, 12 of the 28 Member States are to over 60 percent dependent Russian gas imports - six of them importing all their gas requirements from Russia. The impact of the current crisis will continue to be felt in the long-term. While much of the discussion is currently focused on alleviating the impact of possible gas supply disruptions this winter, it has also enabled a discussion on the role of energy efficiency that was deemed impossible earlier in the year.

A call for greater energy savings was included in the European Commission's spring proposals to improve the EU's security of supply. Indeed, a new target proposal for a 30 percent reduction in energy consumption by 2030 followed suit in July. The new target is 5 percentage points higher than what was originally suggested with the 2030 energy and climate package in January this year. The explicit goal underlying the ambitious energy savings target is to reduce natural gas imports. According to the European Commission's analysis, such a target could reduce European gas imports by a total of 83 billion cubic meters compared to a 2013 baseline outlook for 2030 (equivalent to the annual gas consumption of Germany). Realising such a reduction in gas imports via energy efficiency improvements won't come cheap. To get to the desired reduction in gas imports, the Commission has analysed that marginal system costs would jump from €2 billion per year for a 25 percent effort to €20 billion with a 30 percent target. Costs increase as more expensive investments in energy efficiency would need to be made, especially in the buildings sector - after the "low hanging fruits" in industrial processes would have already been picked. However, lowering gas consumption may not lead to lower imports of Russian gas.

It is true that a reduction in energy consumption would certainly reduce imports for Eastern European countries where Russia is the sole supplier of gas. But in the liberalized Western European gas market where gas is often traded at hubs without "national identity", it is difficult to control the origin of gas imports. Indeed, reducing gas demand in Europe will have consequences on Russia's market positioning and the attractiveness of investments in alternative sources of supply such as LNG. It does not follow that if gas demand and overall imports decline, Russian gas imports will decline, too.
With a large, low cost supply base and depreciated pipeline infrastructure, Russia may actually be better placed to supply a smaller European gas market than other producers: a smaller market may deter investment in LNG supplies and producers will seek alternative markets in Asia or other developing regions. So far the Commission has been relying on indirect means to improve long-term security of supply as within the framework of liberalized, traded markets other options are limited. But the effectiveness of this approach to reduce dependence on Russian gas remains to be seen.
While driving forward energy savings across the EU would certainly enhance performance on sustainability, it has yet to be proved it is an effective foreign policy tool.

By Susanne Hounsell, Associate Director, European Power-Gas-Coal-Renewables, IHS Global, Paris

Posted on November 6, 2014 - (233 views)
Related articles
Workbench for Electrical Cabinet and Low Voltage
Easily print labels from your smartphone!
Turntable Bearings for Medical Applications
Take your temperature measurements to the next level
Custom Engineered Components
Ergonomic Safety Handles
High-Speed Camera with 4 Channels CXP-12
Bolts Configurator with Groove
3D Scanning and Inspection Solutions
Bi-Metal Temperature Gauges
Sensing Innovation in Process and Control
Ultrasonic Flowmeter TRX
Hannay Reels Delivers Every Time
Multi-protocol Network Diagnostics
Take your Manufacturing to the Edge. Connect Everything
Power in new Dimensions - BXT Motor Family
Mechanical Position Sensor MP600 Series
Heaters of H series
3 Phase Book Style EMC Filter
Leading Distributor in Automation & Robotics Technology
High-Speed Camera with 4 Channels CXP-12
Bi-Metal Temperature Gauges
Industrial Wireless LAN Access Points
FMAC NEO: 3-Phase Mains Filter
Cogent DataHub IoT Gateway
Chip Fuse for Highest Demands
SUT-H: for Hgh Inrush Currents
FPBB RAIL - Compact DIN-Rail Filter
DG11: IEC Appliance Plug with Circuit Breaker
Labfacility L60+ Thermocouple & Fine Wire Welder
Easily print labels from your smartphone!
Ergonomic Safety Handles
Bi-Metal Temperature Gauges
Hoist Trolleys
Interactive Projection Module
JVL Shows the Highlight of SPS IPC Drives 2018
Schildknecht Presents the Universal ioT Gateway at SPS IPC Drives 2018
Danfoss Drives Presented its Latest Novelties at SPS IPC Drives 2018
Rockwell Presents the iTrack System at SPS IPC Drives 2018
Microscope Optics by Optris Presented at SPS IPC Drives