Mitigating the Effects of Pulsating Flow in Flow Measurement

  Enquiry / contact me

Titan Enterprises has published a new technical article that discusses how variation in flow velocity can impact flow measurement accuracy and how to mitigate any undesirable effects.

Sensor Technology, Test & Measurement

Figure 1: If sampling is much lower than the pulsations, a random scatter of the flow will be observed, seemingly following no pattern at all
Figure 1: If sampling is much lower than the pulsations, a random scatter of the flow will be observed, seemingly following no pattern at all
Figure 2: The type of aliasing shown below is following a cyclic pattern within the peaks and troughs of the pulse
Figure 2: The type of aliasing shown below is following a cyclic pattern within the peaks and troughs of the pulse
Mitigating the Effects of Pulsating Flow in Flow Measurement
Mitigating the Effects of Pulsating Flow in Flow Measurement

Titan Enterprises. It is well known that flowmeters are sensitive to effects such as pulsating flow which can generate errors in flow measurement. In a pulsating flow system, the velocity profile of the flow undergoes a dramatic change during each cycle of pulsation compared to even flow conditions. So, in electronically sampling flow meters such as ultrasonic devices, the main source of potential error is the rate of sampling and how it will perceive the real flow passing through it.

How can errors generated by the effects of pulsating flow be minimised during sampling?

Titan Enterprises offers a range of Ultrasonic small bore flow meters giving high accuracy flow measurement for a wide range of applications. However, as with all flow metering devices, they are sensitive to installation effects that generate variations in the velocity profile of the flow. Where Titan’s flow meters are installed in a pulsating flow system, we advise customers to dampen any pulsation as much as possible prior to measurement.

Following Nyquist Theorem to increase accuracy of flow measurement

The Nyquist Theorem states that in order to adequately reproduce a signal, (in this case the liquid flow), it should be periodically sampled at a rate that is at least twice as fast as its highest frequency component that is being recorded. Therefore, with a pulsating flow scenario the sampling rate of the electronic flow meter needs to be at least double the Hz rate of the pulsations themselves. If the pulsation rate is not taken into account, aliasing of the flow signal will be seen, resulting in erroneous measurement from the flowmeter.

Aliasing in flow metering

Aliasing can be illustrated in film making with the wagon wheel effect where the camera sampling rate is less than twice the rotations of the spokes of the wheel. The visual effect generated is the wheel reversing its direction, even though the cart continues along its original path.

With flow measurement, aliasing can be illustrated graphically. For example, if sampling is much lower than the pulsations, a random scatter of the flow will be observed, seemingly following no pattern at all (See Figure 1).

Theoretically, sampling at the same frequency as the pulsation would give a constant but incorrect flow measurement. In practice it is rare to see this and the type of aliasing shown below is more likely, following a cyclic pattern within the peaks and troughs of the pulse (See Figure 2).

Titan’s Ultrasonic Flow Meters

All of Titan’s Ultrasonic flow meters use time of flight acoustic flow measurement. By measuring an acoustic signal upstream and downstream in the liquid measurement tube, the velocity – and thus flow – is accurately measured. For example, the Standard Atrato range will measure to ±1% of reading from 2ml/min to 20l/min.

Using advanced electronics, Titan’s Atrato® and Metraflow® ranges of ultrasonic flowmeters are able to resolve the ultrasonic signals to about 50 picoseconds, with repeat measurements made to ensure stability of measurement. The software samples the flow measured every 3 milliseconds (ms), but with the downstream processing the reported flow is effectively filtered to about 50ms or 20Hz.

So, following the Nyquist theory, Titan’s Ultrasonic devices can accurately measure pulsating flow that is less than 10Hz. Pulsating above this will likely lead to aliasing, so inline pulse dampening is always recommended for systems using diaphragm, piston or peristaltic pumps for example.

Posted on March 16, 2021 - (1411 views)
Titan Enterprises Ltd
5a Coldharbour Business Park
DT9 4JW Sherborne - United Kingdom
+44-1935-812790
+44-1935-812890
View full company profile
Location
More products from this supplier
Optimum Coolant Flow
Reliable Turbine Flowmeters Meet Demands of Specialist Coolant Flow Applications
Flow Monitoring in an Explosive Atmosphere
Accurate Flowmeter Ideal for Multiple Water System Applications
Metering Grease Lubrication Flow in a Wind Turbin
NSF-Approved Mini Turbines
Ultrasonic Flowmeter Ideal for Ultra-Pure Water Applications
Titan Enterprises Explains the Factors that Determine Flow Meter Performance
Tutorials for Flow Meter Installation
Keeping A Cool Head With Data Storage
Reliable Turbine Flowmeters Meet Demands of Specialist Coolant Flow Applications
Flow Monitoring in an Explosive Atmosphere
Accurate Flowmeter Ideal for Multiple Water System Applications
Metering Grease Lubrication Flow in a Wind Turbin
NSF-Approved Mini Turbines
Ultrasonic Flowmeter Ideal for Ultra-Pure Water Applications
Upturn in Demand for High Performance Mini Turbine Flowmeters
The Expanding Role of Flow Measurement in Healthcare
In-line Turbine Flow Meters
NSF Certified Turbine Flow Meters
Reliable Turbine Flowmeters Meet Demands of Specialist Coolant Flow Applications
Flow Monitoring in an Explosive Atmosphere
NSF-Approved Mini Turbines
Tutorials for Flow Meter Installation
The Expanding Role of Flow Measurement in Healthcare
Non-invasive Ultrasonic Flowmeter
Ultrasonic Flowmeter for Corrosive Fluids
Advanced Ultrasonic Flowmeter
Ultrasonic Flowmeter for Laboratory
Ultrasonic Flowmeters
Related articles
Automated Quality Control Solutions
Gas Detection Solutions
Compact Spot Finder IR Camera Xi 410 from Optris
All-In-One System for Precise Thickness Measurements in the Line
Ultrasonic Distance Sensor
Hand-held Metrology Grade 3D Scanner
Streamlined Transmitter
Ceramic Pressure Sensor
Upgrading or Replacing Hard-to-Source Optics
Ceramic Pressure Sensors and Oil-Filled Pressure Sensors
Compact Spot Finder IR Camera Xi 410 from Optris
All-In-One System for Precise Thickness Measurements in the Line
Ceramic Pressure Sensors and Oil-Filled Pressure Sensors
VPFlowScope M flow meter: Measure, Discover & Save
High-Performance Laser Distance Sensor for Industrial Applications
VOS 2-D Universal Vision Sensors
Single Board Computer for Real-time Critical Applications
Rugged Smart & Easy-to-Install IR Sensors
Inductive Displacement Measuring System
High-precision Automated Inline 3D Inspection
Compact Spot Finder IR Camera Xi 410 from Optris
All-In-One System for Precise Thickness Measurements in the Line
VPFlowScope M flow meter: Measure, Discover & Save
Mobile Thermal Imagers for Swift On-Site Inspection
New Current Sensor Element and Firmware Upgrade for Award-winning Yokogawa Precision Power Analyzer 
PTC Leverages Spatial Computing Capabilities with Vuforia Engine Area Targets
New High-Speed Pyrometer CT 4M from Optris
Micro Sensor for Temperature, Pressure, Tension, Torsion, Position, Electric Current and Magnetic Field Measurements
HMS Networks Releases the World’s First Industrial 5G Router and Starterkit
New Series of Transducers for High Performance Gaging Probes