Three Reasons to Use Ethernet for Motion Control

  Enquiry / contact me

Ethernet is an increasingly important network in industrial applications, especially for motion control applications require determinism, which is needed to ensure position retention and get precision and proper acceleration/deceleration of drives


Three Reasons to Use Ethernet for Motion Control
Three Reasons to Use Ethernet for Motion Control

When it comes to motion control, Ethernet, fieldbus, and other technologies such as Peripheral Component Interconnect have historically competed with each other for the right to handle some of the most demanding workloads within industrial automation and control systems. Motion control applications require determinism (a guarantee that the network will get workloads to their intended nodes on time), which is needed to ensure position retention, and get in turn precision and proper acceleration/deceleration of drives, among other tasks.

Standard IEEE 802.3 Ethernet

Standard IEEE 802.3 Ethernet has never been up to par in this respect. Even with the CSMA/CD data link layer having become obsolete thanks to full-duplex switching and isolated collision domains, it lacks predictability. Plus, the complexity of TCP/IP higher up in the typical stack is not optimized for the reliable delivery of real-time traffic. As a result, fieldbuses, as well as PC-oriented control architectures with ASIC-based PCI cards, have been popular solutions for motion control.

Ethernet solutions from EtherNet/IP® to EtherCAT® have addressed these shortcomings in their own distinctive ways. Still, industrial Ethernet is far from dominant in motion control, despite some of its other advantages over the alternatives. Let’s examine three reasons why it can and should gain ground on its competition in the years ahead.

1. Convergence Instead of Complexity

Interconnection between enterprise IT and the factory floor has increased over time, leading to complicated systems that often mix standard and industrial Ethernet with fieldbuses. For example, machines might utilize:

  • SERCOS for communicating with servos
  • PROFIBUS® for networking variable frequency drives
  • SafetyBUS p for fail-safe fieldbus communications
  • DeviceNet for connecting to sensors
  • Ethernet, accessed over a gateway, for sending data to end users

Such networks are complex and also expensive to set up and maintain. Each protocol requires its own implementation procedures, installers, and trainings. In contrast, Ethernet offers the possibility of converging the different networks for motion, safety, etc. onto cost-effective infrastructure that is relatively easy to wire, widely supported by vendors, and futureproof.

Ethernet Offers the Possibility of Converging Disparate Networks

The EtherNet/IP protocol exemplifies how convergence can work in practice. An integrated, switched system can accommodate both business and industrial applications through the use of standard Ethernet technologies like TCP/IP and UDP/IP alongside features such as CIP Sync for implementing the IEEE 1588 precision time protocol synchronization of distributed clocks.

2. Determinism for Motion Control Applications

Motion control depends on precise communications. This precision has been supported by the use of time slot-based scheduling, in which each device gets a schedule for communicating with others. A delta-T value is calculated for the control function as these servo drives and controllers figure out their respective timings. However, it can be thrown off if data delivery becomes unpredictable—hence the need for determinism to ensure loop stability.

Ethernet Can Support Demanding Motion Control Applications in Plants

The implementation of IEEE 1588 in EtherNet/IP, in some cases via accelerator circuits installed directly on Intel® chips, is just one common mechanism used by Ethernet solutions to enforce determinism. The on-the-fly processing of EtherCAT is another example of how consistently predictable performance is achieved for motion control applications. EtherCAT goes beyond the strict physical limitations of centralized PCI-based communications, which, while fast, still require short distances between the machine processing unit and servo processors.

“An EtherCAT-based distributed processor architecture has the bandwidth, synchronization, and physical flexibility to match the power of centralized control plus the advantages of a distributed network,” Jason Goerges explained in a 2010 article for Machine Design. “In fact, some processors that use this approach can control up to 64 highly coordinated axes with a 20 kHz sampling and update rate—including position, velocity, and current loops, as well as commutation.”

3. Long-Term Viability for the IIoT

Ethernet has already gone through many permutations since its beginnings as a LAN technology. Whereas legacy fieldbus components are currently manufactured at a small scale and PCI risks are going the way of the obsolete Industry Standard Architecture, Ethernet continues to evolve and is now well-positioned to serve the IP-centric Industrial Internet of Things.

Impending improvements such as time sensitive networking, which will refine IEEE 1588 and bolster the network convergence possibilities as well, also make Ethernet a sound choice for motion control both now and in the future.

This isn’t to say that fieldbus and PCI will go away—only that Ethernet’s advantages continue to mount as the automation industry moves toward the IIoT.

Posted on March 20, 2019 - (426 views)
Analog Devices GmbH
Otl-Aicher-Str. 60-64
80807 München - Germany
+49 89 76903 0
View full company profile
More products from this supplier
Looking Inside Real-Time Ethernet
20 V, 8 A, High Efficiency, Tiny Package Step-Down µModule Device
Multiple Output Cascaded Buck Converter Steps
10 Gbps Full Bandwidth Digital Isolator
Modern LIDAR Systems: Sensing for Every Industry
Seamless Connectivity Fuels Industrial Innovation
Choose the Right Accelerometer for Predictive Maintenance
Analog Devices Presented New AI-driven Platform at electronica 2020
The Autonomous Industrial Revolution
Analog Devices & Microsoft Partner to Mass Produce State-of-the-Art 3D Imaging Products and Solutions
Related articles
Service Management Cloud Solution
AI computing, Network Capabilities and Miniature Design in IPCs
Automated Quality Control Solutions
No-code UniCloud specifically designed for Machine Builders
SPS 2021 - The Hybrid Exhibition Highlight
Cloud-based Solution for Service Management
Distributive IIoT Architecture
Ultra-rugged Computer-on-module for the Transportation Sector
Leeds Digital Festival: Specialist Sessions Target Application of Digital Technologies in Manufacturing and Utilities
Cobot MELFA ASSISTA. Human Touch. Industrial Performance
SPS Smart Production Solutions - November 23 to 25, 2021
MELFA ASSISTA Collaborative Robot from Mitsubishi Electric
Pepperl+Fuchs Series UC18GS Ultrasonic Sensor with IO-Link
JUMO variTRON 500 Central Processing Unit for an Automation System
When Automation Goes Digital
Unique IR Solutions
Achema 2021
Two/four-channel Process and Program Controller
Tailor-made Automation Solutions
Fastener Fair France
Ultra-rugged Computer-on-module for the Transportation Sector
Single Board Computer for Real-time Critical Applications
Global Survey Conducted by Molex Highlights Continued Progress in Industry 4.0
Semi-absolute Linear Encoder
JUMO variTRON 500 Central Processing Unit for an Automation System
Customized Membrane Switches for Demanding Applications
Versatile Industrial 5G Router
UniCloud – The Complete, No-Code, IIoT Cloud Platform for OEMs and Machine Builders by Unitronics
AC Servo Drives & Motors
Variable Frequency Drives
Cloud-based Solution for Service Management
Distributive IIoT Architecture
Ultra-rugged Computer-on-module for the Transportation Sector
Managed Service Suite Platform for Plant Asset Performance
Lilly Life Science Studio Automated Laboratory Goes Further in the Search For New Drugs
IERA 2021 Awarded to ABB's PixelPaint Solution
More Machining and Less Programming: ESPRIT Keeps the Success Flowing for WET
AC Servo Drives & Motors
Unistream®, the Award-Winning Programmable Controllers Series With Integrated HMI by Unitronics
Automated 3D Scanning and Inspection of Transport Stands