How do I measure

  Enquiry / contact me

The Effect of Pulsating Flow on Flow Measurement Accuracy

Sensor Technology, Literature & Services

Fig. 1
Fig. 1
Fig. 2
Fig. 2

Flow meter manufacturers calibrate their products in steady flow conditions for a very good reason. Pulsations cause big errors.
Dealing with pulsating flow has been an issue in flow measurement for over 100 years. In the 1920’s a gentleman called John Lawrence Hodgson working for George Kent Ltd identified that pulsations induced in fluid flow caused serious reading errors with differential pressure meters. He has several flow related patents and developed the Hodgson number HN which when calculated to be greater than “2” showed the error in flow would be less than 1%. It is a simple formula with just five terms (Fig.2)

V. Volume of pipework between pulsation source and flow meter
f. The frequency of the pulsations
Qv. Volumetric flow rate
∂P Pressure drop between the source of the pulsations and the flow meter
P Absolute pressure at the meter.

Consequently if the flow meter is a long way from the pulsations and the line has a reasonable pressure drop the error would be reduced. This is largely still true today but modern flow meters complicate matters somewhat.

There are many types of pulsation source. The pump is a common source of pulsations particularly with smaller flows of aggressive chemicals where it is a frequent problem. How your flowmeter behaves will depend on the meter type, where it is positioned as well as the frequency and amplitude of the pulsations. A diaphragm pump can produce very severe pulsations with periods of zero flow whereas a gear pump will produce a fairly steady flow with a small “ripple” in the delivery rate. Other pump types come somewhere between these two extremes.

Turbine flow meters will generally have too much inertia to respond to velocity changes and will therefore run at something like the RMS velocity of a sinusoidal velocity profile. Positive displacement meters however will cope very well with pulsations as there is virtually no “slippage” of fluid past the measuring chamber. These flow meters will however sometimes induce pulsations of their own into the flow.
Electronic based devices have a different problem in that they have their own internal cycle times which take “slices” of flow information and report the answer. Depending where these “slices” are relative to the pulsation can cause very large reading errors due to this aliasing.

The best solution for accurately measuring pulsating flow is to remove the pulsations. This can be achieved by siting the flow meter as far away as possible from the source. This will give the pulsations time to attenuate. Increasing the pressure drop in the line will also help as long as sufficient pressure remains at the flow meter for accurate measurement. In liquid systems a hydraulic accumulator of some description with a gas bladder is very effective. If this is not possible a “tuned” column of air has been shown to work but this does need continuous monitoring for the best results. Any accumulator of this type is only likely to be effective for a given set of flow conditions and pulsation type. Also note that changing the flow rate or pump and the system will have to be re-tuned.
 

Posted on February 21, 2018 - (28920 views)
Titan Enterprises Ltd
5a Coldharbour Business Park
DT9 4JW Sherborne - United Kingdom
+44-1935-812790
+44-1935-812890
View full company profile
Location
More products from this supplier
Low Cost Rate and Total Flow Indicator
Non Invasive Low Flow Ultrasonic Flowmeter
Non-invasive Ultrasonic Flowmeter
Flow measurement in F1 racing cars
Ultrasonic Flowmeter for Low Flow Applications
Chemically inert ultrasonic flowmeter
Beverage Dispensing Flowmeters
Ultrasonic Flowmeter for Corrosive Fluids
The Challenge of Metering the Flow of Liquids
Advanced Ultrasonic Flowmeter
Related articles
Wireless-based Pressure Transmitters and Receivers
Fast Ethernet Connected Sensor
LMI Technologies Acquires FocalSpec
LVDT Position Sensors
Artificial Intelligence Starts with Sensors
Intrinsically Safe Humidity and Temperature Sensor
7.1 Megapixels EXO Industrial Camera
AMA Innovation Award 2020
Infrared Temperature Sensors for Almost Any Application, Even ATEX Zone 0
Micro-Epsilon UK to Showcase Its Sensor Technology Solutions
Santest Mechatronic Range
MP600 Mechanical Position Sensors
MP600 Mechanical Position Sensors
Sensorik4.0®, a gateway to Industry 4.0
MP600 Mechanical Position Sensors
Micro-Epsilon Capacitive Sensors
Sensing Innovation for Process & Control
Sensors & Instrumentation Live from 25 to 26 September 2019
Sensing Technology for Process and Control
Accurate Laser Sensors
MP600 Mechanical Position Sensors
MP600 Mechanical Position Sensors
Sensorik4.0®, a gateway to Industry 4.0
MP600 Mechanical Position Sensors
Images and Height Profiles Analysis
Laser Triangulation Measurement Sensors
Thermal Fuse with Shunt Resistor
Enhanced Multi-Gas Detector
Electricity Generators From Tidal Streams
Unmatched Precision in Distance and Thickness Measurements with Confocal Sensors